I’ve been trying to figure out why Abraham Lincoln was called “Honest.” I’ve read various explanations. Some of them seem like folk lore, intended for elementary school teachers to tell their students. For example, when young Abraham worked as a store clerk, he realized that he overcharged one of his customers by a few pennies. He then walked a bunch of miles to the person’s house and returned the pennies. He probably wanted to brag about how the penny featured an image of him…
I also read that when he worked as a lawyer, he would often help poor people for free. That doesn’t really seem honest, actually.
The last explanation is incredibly dubious and will most likely not be used by 2nd grade teachers: Abe Lincoln got the nickname “Honest Abe” for his work as a cockfight official.
In the three examples, it sounds more appropriate to call him, “Stalker Abe,” “Robin Hood Abe,” and “Creepy Abe.”